Guides · Upholstery

Can the fabric be changed once production has started?

Guides · Upholstery

In brief. It can, and on a hotel project it often is. What changes is not whether it is possible but what the decision costs, and that cost turns on a single fact: how far into the work the request arrives. Before cutting it is a variation; after cutting it is remaking; and the line between the two belongs in writing at the start, not in an argument at the end.

What actually happens when the covering is changed?

An upholstered piece is not an object onto which fabric is laid at the end. The covering enters the work far earlier, and it passes through a sequence that cannot be run backwards: the fabric is committed with the mill, it arrives in the workshop, it is inspected roll by roll, it is laid out and cut to a plan calculated for that model and that pattern repeat, it is sewn, and only then does it dress the frame and the filling.

While the work is still short of the commitment to the mill, changing fabric means changing a line in the order: what is lost is the time of whoever had already done the arithmetic, and nothing more. After cutting, the fabric no longer exists as a roll: it exists as a set of pieces shaped for one particular model, which are of no use on another model and which will not match on another pattern repeat. That irreversibility, and not any ill will on the supplier's part, is why the same request costs nothing on Monday and a great deal on Friday.

Where exactly is the point of no return?

In practice three moments matter, and they are worth knowing because they are the three moments at which somebody can still say no at no cost.

The first is approval of the covering. It is the point at which the studio or the client confirms the reference, the colour and the direction of the pattern, normally on a sample set or in the mock-up room. Until that confirmation arrives nobody commits material: we write about it in «the hotel mock-up room» (/en/guides/hotel-mock-up-room).

The second is the commitment of material with the fabric supplier. From here on there is an order placed with a third party, with its own conditions, and withdrawal is no longer free for either side.

The third is cutting. That is the real point of no return. After cutting, a piece is remade rather than changed, and the whole difference in cost sits between those two words.

Whoever runs the supply ought to confirm in writing, with a date, when the second and third stages are entered. It is the only way the client can decide while knowing what is being decided, and it follows the logic of the supply calendar we describe in «the lead time of a hotel supply» (/en/guides/hotel-ffe-lead-time).

Why does a change of covering also affect the certificates?

This is the part that gets discovered late on site, and it matters more than all the rest. The reaction-to-fire class of an upholstered piece is not a property of the fabric: it is a property of the combination of covering and filling with which that covering was tested. Changing the cover is therefore not a cosmetic amendment that leaves the paperwork intact: it is a new assembly, and it needs documentary cover of its own.

Two practical consequences follow. The first is that it is not enough for the new fabric to be «a contract fabric»: it has to be covered in that particular pairing. The second is that the dossier accompanying the supply has to be redone so that it describes the article actually delivered, rather than the one approved months earlier. On how these documents are read, and on holding together a piece made of several materials, we have two dedicated guides: «fire-rated hotel furniture» (/en/guides/fire-rated-hotel-furniture) and «furniture made of several materials» (/en/guides/multi-material-furniture-approval). The parallel case of a covering replaced on a piece already in use is dealt with in «reupholstery and the fire certificate» (/en/guides/reupholstery-fire-certificate).

The moment to ask the question is when the change is requested, not when the goods are delivered. A covering chosen well for its colour and impossible to document in that pairing is a variation that is blocked before it starts.

What is actually being paid for?

It is worth separating the items, because when a change request comes back refused with a single figure attached, nobody can tell what is being argued about. There are four: material already committed or already cut, which stays with the project because it does not go back into stock; work already carried out, the hours of whoever calculated the cutting plan, cut and sewed; the new material, with its own price and availability, which need not be that of the first; and time, which in a hotel weighs more than any of the others, because an opening date moved back costs more than any fabric.

None of these has a value that can be written down in general: it depends on quantity, on how far the work has gone and on the fabric. What can be insisted upon is that they be separated in a legible variation quotation, and that the answer arrive with an updated delivery date next to the price. A price without a new date is not a complete answer.

How to word it in the order, so as not to argue later

Three lines in the contract or the order confirmation head off almost every argument that arises once work has begun.

The first sets the moment beyond which a change request becomes chargeable, referring to the stage rather than to a bare calendar date: approval of the covering, commitment of material, cutting. The second requires the supplier to confirm in writing the passage into each subsequent stage. The third sets out how a variation is handled: a separate quotation itemised by heading, a new delivery date, and a note of which documents are being redone. Where a specification exists, that is where these lines sit best: we write about it in «the specification clause» (/en/guides/hotel-furniture-specification).

A fourth line is worth adding, and almost nobody writes it: what becomes of the material left over. Fabric committed and not used can sometimes be recovered on another batch of the same project if it is still with the mill; if nobody asks, it is written off.

How we work

We make the upholstery in house, in our own workshop, alongside the wood, the marble and the ironwork. On a change of covering that alters something concrete: the decision does not travel down a chain of subcontractors before coming back as a figure, and the cutting plan is redone where it was drawn up in the first place. What stays long is the part that does not depend on us, namely the availability of the new fabric.

On a hotel project the most important value is time: products that comply, that are certified and that are delivered on schedule mean an opening that is not postponed, and a hotel that opens begins to invoice. That is why we treat a change request as a decision with an expiry date, and the first thing we say is by when it can still be taken without moving the delivery.

The work and the materials can be seen in the collections (/en/collections); the route of a project supply is described in the contract (/en/contract) section; the questions studios put to us most often, answered in writing, are in «the questions a studio asks us» (/en/studio-questions); and the contact details (/en/contact) lead to the people who follow the project.

Up to when can the fabric be changed at no cost? Up to the commitment of material with the supplier. The useful reference is not a date in the diary but the stage of the work, and the stage should be asked for and confirmed in writing: a supplier can always say whether the fabric has been committed and whether it has been cut.

Does the new fabric need the same certificate as the first? It needs to be covered in the pairing with the filling used in that piece, which is not the same thing as «having a certificate». It is the combination that is classified, not the fabric on its own, and the supply documentation has to be updated accordingly.

Can the fabric be changed on only part of the project? It can, and it happens when one area of the hotel is rethought. How future replacements are handled has to be agreed at the same time, though: a batch split between two coverings needs reserve material kept for both, or the difference will show in two years' time.

What if the new fabric behaves differently over time? That is a real risk, and it is assessed beforehand rather than afterwards: abrasion resistance and the surface behaviour of a fabric are read quite differently from the way a sample lying on a table is read. We write about it in «how many Martindale rubs» (/en/guides/martindale-how-many-rubs-hotel) and in «fabric pilling» (/en/guides/fabric-pilling-after-six-months-defect).

Talk to us The contract division

This page sets out assessment criteria and working practice; it quotes no prices, no lead times and no company case studies. The practical indications have to be checked against the actual case, because they depend on the contract, the building and the project. No technical standard is cited: requirements change with the intended use of the rooms.